RPG Reviews

RPG reviews are completely messed up. The vast, vast majority of reviewers have no experience with the actual product in question. They've never run the module, never run a full game with the system, and only have conjecture about the content and comments on the art. It seems like just an extension of marketing, rather than an actual look at the merits of a given work. The juice comes out in play, not speculation.

I don't watch video reviews, but I imagine the problem is even worse in that god forsaken realm. Every day I am recommended a Questing Beast video, in which his mouth is agape beside an image of the latest greatest RPG book.

Instead of these, I tend to favour play reports and, especially, retrospectives. They aren't common, and good ones are rare, but even a poor retrospective is worth more than a hundred reviews. Table Top RPGs are enjoyable to me in part because the experience of them is "slow" compared to other mediums. Different player groups and campaigns are also highly unique. You can't review a table top game or module like a review. 

Playing TTRPGs kicks ass, but much of the culture and related "content" (Detritus) is completely backward. I think the reviews are mostly for people who collect games and enjoy them as a conceptual exercise, rather than those who actually play and run RPGs.

Comments

  1. GB NilssonMay 21, 2024 at 11:45 AM

    This is something that has bothered me for a while as well. The equivalent would be basing your movie review only off the screenplay without ever actually having seen the film.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sword, Dao, and Katana: Thinking About Cultural Appropriation and Orientalism

Recently, I finished my Masters in Chinese History. Nice! So, with lots of food to eat and no money to buy any, I looked for jobs and found that a Table Top RPG publisher was looking for East Asian themed adventures. I thought I'd apply and, lo and behold, the publisher was interested. So I wrote up a pitch for an adventure and general world building and sent them in. Even in the initial email exchanges I was already getting somewhat frustrated because the vision that the publisher and I had about what "East Asia" actually meant were totally divergent. "East Asia" in, this case, is really just a product of Western imagination. The goal really wasn't ever to create an East Asian world, but instead to create a fantasy of East Asia compatible with Western tastes. Moreover, the publisher was very interested in historical fidelity which is, I think, quite foolhardy in a game. So... I've got all this material now and have been thinking about finishing up a pol
Read more

Daemonium - Brave Surviver!! Session 14: Adventures in Mirror Mountain

Characters: Za'vak Al-Hadim - Level 3 Paladin/Level 1 Fighter Gene Erikson - Level 4 Fighter Vamp Testy, The Monkey Sympathizer - Level 4 Monk - Huzzah! A session report! As I've just created my bodacious blog you, dear reader, must roll with the punches and jump right into this campaign with little context. The Emperor Regulus, leader of the Aeon Empire, is attempting to conquer the world. The party is made up of individuals that have, for various reasons, joined the Kingdom of Cashua's rebellion against Aeon. Will they manage to survive? The game is run using 5e. In terms of rulings and play procedures, I take a lot from OSR games and FATE. I'd say there's a pretty good balance between gameplay and roleplay, with some players focused a little more on one or the other. In our last episode, Za'vak the Paladin accidentally burnt a child to death in the city of Portia. While some gods may weigh intent as more important than results in terms of ethics, Torm priorit
Read more

A Critique of the 5e Battle Master

In my current 5e campaign, Daemonium, one of my players made their character Gene Erikson a Battle Master Fighter. Despite some initial excitement we found that, in play, the class was a slog to use and didn't really add very much to the gameplay of the character. The issues I have with the Battle Master encapsulate some of the problems I have with 5e as a whole. - Fighters are my favourite RPG class and, for an RPG with a class based character creation system, they are the basis by which I judge the class system. 5e uses a subclass system, in which classes can pick a sort of specialization once they reach level 3 (Level 1 for some classes). The Fighter in 5e has three subclasses in the Player's Handbook (And a million more in the many supplements). You can pick Champion, Eldritch Knight, and Battle Master. Each of these add traits to the basic Fighter package. The basic 5e Fighter is defined by gaining extra attacks as they level. While other fighting man classes in 5e have a
Read more